No Answer from Dr. Liebi, So Far?

HGL'S F.B. WRITINGS: Somewhat Sectarian Style, Semel · Somewhat Sectarian Style, bis · Correspondence of Hans Georg Lundahl: No Answer from Dr. Liebi, So Far? · Stefan Claesemann tries to take it in private with me · Creation vs. Evolution : Let's Carbon Test Stefan Claesemann's Chronology · Correcting the Test

At least I found no answer in my mail and it's already a week from my sending the mail.

Me to Dr. Roger Liebi via Dieu-TV

10/5/2021 at 4:48 PM

Grüezi Dr. Liebi ... "Israel in Egypt"

Can we take it in English from here, as my Swiss German is faulty, I don't doubt your standard German, but English is even more international?

Freilich ist mir Deutsch auch kein Problem, wenn Sie vorziehen! I bin a Weana(r) ...

Also, ein gewisser ... a certain Stefan Clasemann is using your work to prove the Exodus happened in 1606 BC.

I happen to hold with the Roman martyrology, it happened in 1510 BC.

Now, part of the conundrum is whether the Santorini eruption was used by God as part of the 10 plagues.

But assuming it was, another part is, does a carbon date 1606 BC imply the event actually happened 1606 BC?

Here is where it get's interesting, because ... a carbon date of 40 000 BP, I think we might agree here, doesn't mean the event happened 38 000 BC.

This poses the question : did you think over for how long back and why carbon dates are reliable, and how the transition happened?

I did.

A bone of an individual, human or beast, died 2000 years ago will arguably carbon date to 2000 years ago. Or a little more.

But a bone of someone who died before the Flood? Or at Babel?

I think we deal with a gradual rise of C14 in the atmosphere, and that at the Exodus, this was still ongong, in other words, things will carbon date to earlier than they were in reality.

Hans Georg Lundahl

Considering Stefan Clasemann did not give me contact info other than name, and considering the other contact info I found had no result, I must conclude he was in bad faith to pretend I could take the debate with Dr. Liebi, and there may have been a gentlemen's agreement between them, or at least between Dieu-TV and Stefan Clasemann, to deny me all debate. Stonewalling, anyone?/HGL